The job market has enough problems without advertising jobs that don't exist. Now investigators are exposing deceptive listings, lawmakers are demanding answers, and the big employment platforms are finding themselves under scrutiny.
What Happened
Imagine you're looking for work. You've been unemployed for three months, your savings are shrinking, and you're spending several hours a day applying for jobs that seem to disappear into the electronic equivalent of a black hole.
Then you spot something promising on LinkedIn. A remote position. No special experience required. A salary that could reach $75,000 a year.
You apply. You get a response. At last, somebody wants to talk to you.
Unfortunately, they don't want to hire you. They want you to pay them.
That's what journalists at CBC News discovered when they investigated hundreds of supposedly legitimate employment opportunities advertised on LinkedIn and Monster.
The advertisements promoted remote travel-related jobs, often promising attractive earnings and minimal experience requirements. But applicants were being directed toward a multilevel marketing operation associated with Evolution Travel. Instead of receiving a salary, they were asked to pay enrollment fees and ongoing charges to participate in a travel-sales business.
CBC journalists applied to eight positions, sometimes submitting blank résumés. They still received invitations to online recruitment sessions.
Apparently, even a blank résumé could qualify you for an interview. A remarkable breakthrough in modern recruiting.
After CBC presented its findings, LinkedIn removed approximately 900 misleading advertisements. Monster removed another 600. LinkedIn said the listings violated its policies and barred the companies responsible from posting additional jobs.
The companies involved have disputed or disavowed aspects of the recruiting practices. Evolution Travel's representatives told CBC that independent agents had been instructed not to advertise their business opportunities as jobs.
Whatever the internal instructions, the advertisements had already reached job seekers.
And that raises a rather obvious question: Why did it take a television news investigation to get them removed?
Why It Matters
There are several varieties of ghost jobs, and they're worth distinguishing.
Some are outright deceptive advertisements, like those uncovered by CBC, designed to lure job seekers into something other than the employment being promised.
Others are posted by legitimate companies that aren't actively hiring. They may be collecting résumés for future use, testing the availability of candidates, or maintaining the appearance of growth.
Still others are positions that once existed but have been filled, frozen, canceled, or forgotten by the people responsible for removing the advertisements.
From the applicant's perspective, the distinctions can become academic. You spend an hour tailoring your résumé, writing a cover letter, and navigating an application system designed by someone who apparently believes employment should require the patience of a medieval monk.
Then nothing happens.
Of course, not every unanswered application is a ghost job. Employers receive enormous numbers of applications, hiring plans change, and perfectly legitimate positions can disappear overnight.
But there is a difference between a company changing its mind and a company advertising a vacancy it never intended to fill.
And there's another party involved: the employment platforms.
LinkedIn, Indeed, Monster, and other services have built businesses around connecting employers and job seekers. Employers may pay to promote advertisements. Job seekers contribute attention, personal information, and sometimes subscription revenue.
The platforms have an obvious interest in maintaining a large, active marketplace.
That doesn't establish that they deliberately encourage ghost jobs. But it does raise a reasonable question about whether the systems designed to attract advertisements are equally effective at verifying them.
A job posting ought to represent an opportunity to get a job. That seems a fairly modest standard.
New York Moves Toward a Crackdown
New York legislators have decided that employers should at least tell applicants whether a job actually exists.
In June, the state legislature passed Senate Bill S8877, sponsored by Senator Michael Gianaris. As of November 13, the legislation has passed both chambers but has not been signed into law.
The bill would require employers with at least 100 employees, along with covered third-party job posting services, to disclose whether an advertisement represents a current vacancy and when the employer expects to fill it.
If a company is simply collecting résumés for possible future openings, it would have to say so.
Employers would also have to remove advertisements within two weeks after positions are filled. Violations could bring fines starting at $2,500, with increasing penalties for advertisements that remain uncorrected.
This would not eliminate every ghost job. Employers could still change hiring plans, and regulators would have to determine whether misleading advertisements violated the law.
But it would establish a principle that ought to be obvious: Employers should not be permitted to disguise speculative recruiting as immediate employment opportunities.
Pennsylvania has also considered legislation addressing ghost job advertisements, while Texas authorities have investigated LinkedIn's practices.
The approaches differ, and the proposals are not all law. Still, the issue is moving beyond complaints from frustrated applicants and into legislative and regulatory scrutiny.
My Take
For years, employers have complained that job applicants don't understand the hiring process.
Perhaps it's time to ask whether employers understand the applicants.
Consider someone who has been out of work for six months. That person may have submitted hundreds of applications, rewritten a résumé repeatedly, and spent countless hours attempting to satisfy automated screening systems.
Each advertised vacancy represents a small possibility of getting back to work.
When the vacancy isn't real, the applicant loses more than an hour. There is the opportunity cost of pursuing something that never existed, the discouragement of another unanswered application, and the growing suspicion that the entire process is rigged.
That suspicion is dangerous because it eventually attaches itself to legitimate employers as well.
The CBC investigation illustrates a particularly blatant abuse. The New York legislation addresses a broader and more ordinary practice: advertising employment opportunities without clearly disclosing whether anyone is actually being hired.
I don't believe employers should be prohibited from building candidate pipelines. Recruiting ahead of demand is sometimes sensible business practice.
But applicants deserve to know whether they're competing for an actual opening or volunteering their résumés for storage in a corporate database.
And the platforms should have some responsibility for making that distinction visible.
After all, if LinkedIn can tell me who viewed my profile, recommend people I haven't spoken to since 1997, and congratulate me on the professional anniversary of somebody I barely remember, perhaps it can figure out whether an advertised job is real.
Job Postings Should Tell the Truth